139 N Ocean Ave, Suite 204, Patchogue, NY 11772Mon to Fri 9 AM to 7 PM, Sat 10 AM to 2 PMHablo español

(631) 823-7630

Contractors

Certificate of Insurance: Holder vs. Additional Insured

In this article
  1. Why everybody asks for your certificate
  2. Certificate holder vs. additional insured
  3. What New York law says about certificates
  4. How to read a certificate in two minutes
  5. The New York extra: the ACORD 855 NY addendum
  6. Where additional insured status can still fall short
  7. What to do next
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Sources

Quick answer

A certificate holder only receives a copy of your certificate. An additional insured is covered through an endorsement on the policy, and New York law says the certificate itself cannot add or change coverage.

A certificate holder is the person who receives a copy of your certificate of insurance. An additional insured is someone the policy itself covers through an endorsement. The certificate alone gives the holder no coverage and no rights, and under New York's Insurance Law it cannot change what the policy says.

Why everybody asks for your certificate

Hand a general contractor your certificate of insurance and a second request usually follows: "Can you add us as additional insured?" In construction, the certificate is the handshake. Everybody asks for one, and fewer people read one.

There is a reason owners and general contractors care. Labor Law section 240(1) puts a duty on contractors, owners and their agents to provide scaffolds, ladders, hoists and other safety devices on building work, and the state's highest court has called it a "strict liability statute" in Runner v. New York Stock Exchange (2009). Owners of one- and two-family homes who contract for the work but do not direct or control it are excepted. That helps explain why "additional insured" shows up in so many subcontracts. If you want the paperwork basics first, start with our contractor insurance page.

Certificate holder vs. additional insured

Sources: New York insurance regulator's counsel (opinion 10-09-12, 2010), New York Insurance Law Article 5 and the NYC Bar Association's November 2, 2017 letter to DFS, all read on November 11, 2026.

Certificate holderAdditional insured
What it isThe party named on the certificate to receive a copyA party the insurer adds to the policy at the policyholder's request
Does it come with coverage?No, the certificate confers no rightsYes, as far as the endorsement says
Where it comes fromThe certificate, usually an ACORD 25An endorsement attached to the policy
What proves itThe certificate itselfThe endorsement form and the policy
Common examplesA town, a lender, a landlordA general contractor or a building owner

The regulator's counsel was asked the question directly: is "certificate holder" the same as "additional insured"? The answer in the 2010 opinion was no. The opinion adds that a certificate may not name an entity as an additional insured unless the policy actually includes that entity.

In plain English

Think of the certificate as a photo of the policy and the endorsement as a seat at the table. Being in the photo does not get you a seat.

What New York law says about certificates

New York added Article 5 of the Insurance Law, "Certificates of Insurance," in 2014 and 2015, according to the Department of Financial Services (DFS). In plain words:

  • A certificate cannot change the policy. Section 502 says a certificate cannot amend, extend or alter the coverage in the policy it refers to, and cannot give anyone rights beyond what the policy expressly provides.
  • Nobody can demand made-up wording. No one may willfully require a certificate to include terms, conditions or language of any kind that the policy does not expressly include. Bid solicitations may list minimum requirements, and anyone may ask for clarification about a policy or endorsement.
  • Approved forms. For liability certificates required for contract work, the form must be the insurer's own or a standard form DFS has approved. DFS's list shows the ACORD 25 (2025/12 edition, approved November 13, 2025) and the ACORD 855 NY construction addendum.
  • Penalties exist. After notice and a hearing, DFS can fine a person who willfully violates Article 5 $1,000 for a first violation and $2,000 for later ones. The fine does not apply to government entities.

Albany is looking at this too. Senate bill S6569, the Certificate of Insurance Reliability Act, would require insurers, not brokers, to issue certificates and would make each one binding on the insurer that issues it. On November 11, 2026, the Senate's page showed it in committee, so the rules above are the ones that apply today. I'm a broker, not a lawyer, so treat all of this as a map. Your attorney can read your contract.

How to read a certificate in two minutes

Nassau County's insurance requirements for home improvement licenses list what a certificate should show, and the list works as a general checklist.

  1. Your legal name, spelled exactly like your paperwork.
  2. Policy number and dates. Is the policy in force for the whole job?
  3. Limits that match what the contract asks for.
  4. Description of operations, in specific words that match your actual work.
  5. Certificate holder, with the exact name and address of whoever asked.
  6. Signature of the authorized representative.
  7. Workers' comp is its own animal. The Workers' Compensation Board says an ACORD form is not acceptable proof of New York workers' comp for a government permit, so the insurer sends Form C-105.2 instead.

Ask for the form number

If a contract says "additional insured," do not stop at a certificate that mentions it. Ask your broker for the endorsement's form number and a copy of the endorsement. That page, not the certificate, is what a lawyer will want to see.

Questions about your own situation?

Call or WhatsApp me at (631) 823-7630. I answer in English and Spanish.

The New York extra: the ACORD 855 NY addendum

The standard ACORD 25 lists limits, insurers and dates. It does not list exclusions, which is the heart of the NYC Bar committees' 2017 complaint: a certificate does not show policy provisions, such as height exceptions or lead-based paint exclusions, that an owner's counsel would want to review before approving a contractor.

New York has a partial answer. DFS's approved list includes ACORD 855 NY, a construction addendum that attaches to an ACORD 25. The sample posted by a state authority asks, among other things:

  • whether the policy restricts work by location, building height or type of construction
  • which additional insured endorsement forms are attached
  • whether the additional insured has primary and non-contributory coverage
  • whether the additional insured gets advance notice if the insurer cancels
  • whether the policy excludes claims for injury to employees of the named insured or subcontractors
  • whether earth movement, excavation, collapse or underground damage is excluded or restricted

The addendum says it is informational and confers no rights. The NYC Bar letter said it is rarely used. That letter is nine years old, so ask whether the other side wants one for your job.

Where additional insured status can still fall short

A line on a certificate that says "additional insured" feels like proof. It is not. The endorsement and the policy still decide. The NYC Bar committees pointed to New York decisions in which certificates of insurance were found non-binding because only the terms of the underlying policy controlled.

The courts keep making the point. In December 2025 the Appellate Division, Second Department said a certificate of insurance is evidence of a contract for additional insured coverage but not conclusive proof of one (Island Trees Union Free School District v. A-1 Construction Services, 2025 NY Slip Op 07289, as summarized by the New York Appellate Digest). With no proof of a specific agreement to name the district, its request for an early ruling that the insurer had to defend it was denied.

Example

A framing sub gets this line in a contract: "Contractor shall name Owner and General Contractor as additional insureds." He sends over a certificate that lists both as certificate holders. Weeks later the general contractor's lawyer asks for the endorsement. The sub's policy has no such endorsement, and the certificate cannot create one. The fix would have been a request to the insurer before the job began. This is an invented example, not a prediction about any policy.

Watch out

A certificate can look perfect and still lead nowhere. Typing "additional insured" onto one does not make anyone an additional insured, and a certificate says nothing about the days after the policy period printed on it. Put the expiration date on your calendar and ask for the endorsement.

What to do next

If you are giving a certificate:

  1. Read the contract's insurance clause first and copy the exact limits, party names and additional insured wording.
  2. Send that clause to your broker before the job starts, with each party's legal name and address.
  3. Ask for the endorsement form number and a copy, not only the certificate.
  4. Keep a folder with the certificate, the endorsement, the policy dates and a renewal reminder.

If you are asking for one: put the coverage, the limits and the wording you need into the contract, ask for the certificate on an approved form, and ask for a copy of the endorsement.

Other paperwork has its own rules. Licenses can ask for specific certificate wording, as in our guide to home improvement license insurance in Suffolk, Nassau and NYC. Whether a CE-200 fits is a different question from whether a certificate does. And if the contract also covers your pickup, see personal or commercial auto for a work truck.

Questions about a certificate for a real job? Send me the contract's insurance clause and I'll go through it with you in plain words. For the coverage behind the paperwork, read about general liability for contractors.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a certificate holder and an additional insured?

A certificate holder is the person or business named on the certificate to receive a copy. An additional insured is added to the policy by the insurer through an endorsement, at the policyholder's request. The state insurance regulator's counsel said in a 2010 opinion that the two terms are not synonymous.

Does a COI mean I am covered under the other company's policy?

Not by itself. The standard certificate says it confers no rights on the holder, and New York's Insurance Law bars a certificate from giving anyone rights the policy does not expressly provide. You are covered only if the policy includes you, usually through an additional insured endorsement, and only as far as that endorsement goes.

How do I ask for an additional insured endorsement?

Send your broker or insurer the insurance clause from the contract and the full legal name of the party to be added, then ask for the endorsement form number and a copy of the endorsement itself. The insurer decides whether to issue it, and nothing is in place until the insurer confirms it in writing.

Why did my general contractor reject my certificate?

I can't see your certificate, but a mismatch with the contract is the usual cause: the name, the dates, the limits, the description of operations, the holder's name or the additional insured wording. Ask the contractor to point to the exact line, and send that line to your broker.

Can anyone make me put wording on a certificate that my policy doesn't have?

In New York, the Insurance Law says no one may willfully require a certificate to include terms, conditions or language of any kind that the policy does not expressly include. There are exceptions, including bid solicitations that list minimum requirements and requests for clarification about the policy. Ask your lawyer about a specific contract.

How long does a certificate stay good?

Only through the policy period printed on it, and only as accurate as the policy was on the day it was issued. When the policy renews, changes or is cancelled, ask for a fresh certificate and check the endorsement again.

Sources

  1. NY Insurance Law section 502, Article 5 certificates of insurance, prohibitions (revision shown July 31, 2015) nysenate.gov
  2. NY Insurance Law section 501, definitions nysenate.gov
  3. NY Insurance Law section 503, enforcement nysenate.gov
  4. NY Department of Financial Services: Certificates of Insurance dfs.ny.gov
  5. NY Department of Financial Services: List of approved certificates of insurance dfs.ny.gov
  6. NY Insurance Department, Office of General Counsel: Opinion 10-09-12, certificate holder and additional insured (September 27, 2010) dfs.ny.gov
  7. NYC Bar Association committees: letter to DFS on insurance certificate transparency in New York construction (November 2, 2017) nycbar.org
  8. NY State Senate: bill S6569, Certificate of Insurance Reliability Act (status checked November 11, 2026) nysenate.gov
  9. New York Appellate Digest: summary of Island Trees UFSD v. A-1 Construction Services (Second Department, December 24, 2025) newyorkappellatedigest.com
  10. ACORD 855 NY, New York construction certificate of liability insurance addendum (2014/05 sample posted by a state authority) dasny.org
  11. NY Workers' Compensation Board: Requirements for businesses applying for government permits, licenses or contracts (fact sheet, version dated July 2019) wcb.ny.gov
  12. Nassau County Department of Consumer Affairs: Insurance requirements for home improvement licenses nassaucountyny.gov
  13. NY Labor Law section 240 nysenate.gov
  14. Runner v. New York Stock Exchange, NY Court of Appeals (December 17, 2009) law.cornell.edu

Rules, limits and fees change. Check the source for the latest, and ask me about your own situation.

Share

For your business

Let's get your business in front of the right markets

Send me the details. I can request quotes from the commercial insurers and wholesale markets I work with, then explain the options in plain words.

Or message me on WhatsApp, or pick a time.

There's no fee for a quote. A quote is not coverage. How I'm paid.

Contractors · 7 min read

CE-200 in New York: Who Can Use It for a Building Permit

A CE-200 is a Workers' Compensation Board exemption certificate for one permit, license or contract, and only for a business with no employees. It is not insurance, and anyone on your crew means you need real coverage.

Contractors · 7 min read

Home Improvement License Insurance: Suffolk, Nassau, NYC

Suffolk, Nassau and New York City each license home improvement contractors on their own. Nassau prints its liability limits, Suffolk's code sets what the county may ask for, and NYC wants workers' comp proof plus a Trust Fund or bond.

Personal insurance · 7 min read

SUM Coverage in New York: What It Is and Who Needs It

SUM is the New York coverage for your injuries when the other driver has no insurance or lower limits than you carry, in New York or out of state. It goes up to your own bodily injury limits and can be declined in writing.